One comment before I get to the list: I cannot stand that the episodes air in different orders in the US and Canada. Are Canadians and Americans so different that they have to be told the story in a different way? I will never understand this.
(Last week's ranking in parentheses)
9 (7). Peter Stone
It's a second straight week in decline for Peter, mainly because he's done next to nothing. I'll give him props for helping out Sav and taking his possibly-maybe-not really-but kinda-arranged future wife to the formal. Not that she deserved him.
Anyways, as much as I love Season Nine so far, the dirty little secret is that I'm having a hard time filling out the power rankings. Basically the decision for the final spot came down to this: an old classic (Spinner), some new Niners that I'm not yet sold on (KC, Clare, Connor, Jenna), or some middle of the road upperclassmen (Danny, Chantay), or Peter. Spinner hasn't really done anything, although he was on fire during "Holiday Road" and may have had the best line of the season so far. ("Rebound eating? It's no way to end up in the wonderful world of meat. No, no, no, no. No deal.") I know that we're supposed to buy KC as the new Sean (checkered past, no parental support, impressionable, a hot temper, and now, a taste for alcohol) but I'm just not loving it. Clare is some kind of hybrid Emma/Liberty to Alli's Manny, but hasn't done much other than whine. Connor is Toby 2.0, which means we don't see nearly enough of him (really). Jenna intrigues me, but she's not list worthy yet. As for Danny and Chantay... let's just say it was a rocky start for the two of them as a "power couple."
This leaves us with Peter. Though he's done nothing lately, he still carried this season at the start, which was huge. Take away any of those characters that I just mentioned, and the show doesn't miss much (with the exception of Spinner, who is largely sentimental at this point). Peter doing meth (and assuming it was coke) was still a better storyline than anyone from this litter has turned in this year.
8 (3). Riley Stavros
Ah, the most problematic character on the list. On the one hand, Riley delivered us what is the likely best story of the year. On the other hand, he's got virtually no value when he's not the leading character. I can't think of a single other "major" character in Degrassi history who has been as all or nothing as Riley. Please allow me to quote from Volume Two of the DS9PR: "Riley's not a character who can float effortlessly into the background of other episodes. He's either the central character, or he's likely no in the episode at all.... I'm worried that the show won't find enough ways to use him." It'd be hard to keep him off of this list because of "Beat It," but I can't really keep him in the top tier without some versatility.
7 (6). Dave Turner
KC had a season's head start, but Dave is my pick for the leading male Niner. He's funnier, a better actor, and seems to fit seamlessly with other characters. For the record, I'm a huge backer of Bhandurner; let's hope they get together. Dave pushed Alli in a good way. She needs someone like Dave, because unchecked, Alli can be insufferable at times. All of this was summed up in this perfect exchange:
Dave: See, this is why I don't like you.
Alli: How can you not like me?!
6 (5). Holly Jeanette Sinclair
I've liked Holly J more than I expected to this year. She's also kind of like the anti-Riley; it seems that she MUST appear in every episode. Somehow, Holly J is the glue that connects the older characters. Heck, she even factored into Marco's storyline. As I mentioned last week, Holly J is the show's lead female. Even though I like others more, it would be hard to knock her off the list given what she's brought to the show this year. And once again, she's not done. I'm still pulling for a Spinner-Jane-Declan-Holly J love rhombus to break out at some point, but even without one, the Holly J-Declan relationship should provide enough fodder on its own.*
*By the way, I'm not totally off-put by the way the show has cooled its jets with the Holly J-Declan relationship. I think it's been smart to let the two of them hang around in the background of most episodes, rather than push them to the front and rush the drama. One thing that has been particularly noticeable this season with all of the new characters is that it has been hard to find natural ways to work everyone in. If Holly J's purpose is to facilitate connections for characters, I think that's a smart play.
5 (4). Fiona Coyne
I haven't lost the faith. Something big has to be coming.
4 (8). Anya MacPherson
I never really thought that I would feel much one way or the other for the Sav-Anya relationship. Boy, was I wrong. I feel for them both. In truth, the "Broken Promises" storyline should have been intolerable - it was a formulaic 'couple has misunderstanding, leads to unnecessary breakup' storyline. In reality, it worked. It felt real (at least, as real as anything ever feels on Degrassi) and I ached for both of them. Why? Because at their core, Sav and Anya are both good, decent people who deserve good things. Yes, there was a fair amount of deceit (on both ends), but it came from a good place, as both want to make the other happy but have their own baggage. In the past, it was hard to be moved by any breakup because at least one of the characters would have deserved it (Craig) or at least one of the characters would have been so miserable that it was hard to picture a relationship with that person being a good thing (Ashley). With Anya and Sav, neither of these was the case. They need to get back together.
3 (9). Alli Bhandari
Why does Alli rank four places ahead of Dave? Two reasons. First, in addition to the whole Bhandurner, we finally got to see the fiercely loyal Alli. If you were a ninth grade KC or Jenna,* you would absolutely have Alli come after you in defense of her best friend. I'm not always a huge advocate of attacking people for decisions like the KC-Clare-Jenna thing (which likely just compounds the problem anyways), but it wouldn't have been believable for Alli to sit on the sidelines here. Manny would have done it for Emma, after all. So although Alli won't get points for tact ("Go tip a cow or something"), I do give her points for her loyalty to Clare.
*Recycled Storyline Alert: Male character gets in trouble with his current girlfriend for flirting with another bikini-clad girl... at a car wash! Where have we seen this before?
The second reason I love Alli is because of her relationship with Sav. Of all of the relationships Degrassi has explored, it's never really done too much with brothers and sisters. Ashley/Toby was a missed opportunity. Ditto for Spinner/Kendra. Danny/Liberty gave us a little bit more, but not much, as did Paige/Dylan. Clare/Darcy? Please. Heather and Holly J cannot appear together, for obvious reasons. Has there been anyone else?
Season Nine has given us one fairly high profile brother-sister duo (Declan/Fiona, more on this in a minute), as well as the terrific Bhandari pair. Alli and Sav rarely appear together at school - which make sense - but their home interactions this year have been priceless.
2 (2). Declan Coyne
The Declan-Fiona relationship ("When you're not happy, I'm not happy") could be one of the best things to ever hit Degrassi... or it could be one of the creepiest. Something is just not right with this duo. It could be sweet, or it could turn horribly, inappropriately wrong. Either way, there's a ton of potential with this pairing. I could see Fiona and Holly J throwing down over Declan. I could see Declan playing the protective older brother (which he already has begun to, in a way). I could also see the two of them harboring some deep, dark secrets, which may be the biggest wild card that Season Nine has yet to play.
The RDTotP!
Is there a rhyme or reason to the way Degrassi employs pop-culture references? Why does the show reference a real celebrity/show in one breath ("She's no Lea Michelle") and then in another come up with a hilariously awful fake alternative ("Did you catch 'So You Believe You Can Boogie' last night?")? I don't get this.
1 (1). Sav Bhandari
Without a doubt. The funniest character of the season finally turned in the type of performance that I never thought he could (or should, for that matter) handle. The downside is that he's now split with Anya, which opens him up for more dramatic stories in the form of an inevitable relationship with someone else (Holly J?). I've already mentioned that I actually did think the Sav/Anya break-up was well done. I should also add that I felt the whole pregnancy scare was handled well, too.* Again, it felt real and from what we saw, Anya and Sav actually had a (somewhat) reasonable conversation about it. And though Sav may have been a touch blunt in encouraging Anya to take the morning after pill, I do believe that he had her best interests at heart.
*Of course we would get a morning after pill episode; how did I not see this coming? We've touched on condoms, abortion, adoption, teenage parenting... In hindsight, using the morning after pill was an obvious choice.
Even though he pulled off the serious episode, I still contend that Sav needs to be deployed primarily as comic relief. I don't think that I need to beat anyone over the head with this point: Sav is versatile enough to pop up in plenty of scenes, which I find to be a good thing because he's consistently funny. That's why he's Number One. Let's close with two of my favorite recent Sav-isms.
Mr. Bhandari: I keep saying, Sav, 'cool' doesn't pay the bills.
Sav: And I keep saying, Dad, I don't have any bills.
...
Anya: It can make me barf for days.
Sav: You know what barfs for months? A baby.